Scott Allan’s World

• Haley Scarnato

Wow. Great legs. Did she sing tonight? Oh yes, her best so far.

• Chris Richardson

Good performance for him. Sings through his nose a bit.

• Stephanie Edwards

She looked like was really holding back. Way too serious. I was a little disappointed tonight.

• Blake Lewis

Fantastic performer. Very unique. Better voice then he gets credit for. He has a great talent for arranging songs. I think he should be top 3.

• Lakisha Jones

Maybe not her best performance, but even on her worst night she’s still really, really good. Great natural talent. She was being measured against her past performances, not against anyone else. Could win it all, definitely top 3.

• Phil Stacey

Good song. Started off strong. Ended Strong. Just ok in the middle. He is lacking in charisma and he won’t be improving that too much in the next few weeks. He does much better when I’m not looking at the tv.

• Jordin Sparks

She’s probably the most underrated contestant. She’s really cute and I really like her voice. She is a little too gooey, happy sometimes, but that’s probably just her age. She acts five years older when she’s singing though. Great job tonight.

• Sanjaya Malakar

Terrible. I don’t how he’s gotten here. The creepy factor is still there. He sings worse and worse each week. If you want to torture me, vote for him. Too many 8 year old girls have access to a phone.

• Gina Glocksen

You can’t help rooting for her. She probably tries harder and wants it more than anyone else. She looks like she would be fun to hang out with. She gave a typical Gina performance. If she could just loosen up a little bit more, her voice would match her personality.

• Chris Sligh

Aren’t you always surprised at the voice that comes out of this guy? Not his best performance this week. I’d like to see him around a few more weeks. I’ve forgiven him for insulting Sweet Home Alabama.

• Melinda Doolittle

She has a great name. She doesn’t really need any personality with a voice like that. In my opinion, she’s the best singer in the competition with Lakisha a close second. I didn’t love the song, but she sure did sing it well. She sounds very professional already. She’s one of my top 3 choices, and based on voice talent only, she should win.

Technorati Tags American Idol, Haley Scarnato, Chris Richardson, Stephanie Edwards, Blake Edwards, Lakisha Jones, Phil Stacey, Sanjaya Malakar, Gina Glocksen, Chris Sligh, Melinda Doolittle